SHIP STABILITY, THEORY AND PRACTICE · VOLUME TWO · APPLIED STABILITY AND TRIM

Chapter 6 · Trim, MCTC and the Centre of Flotation

The book turns lengthways: the pivot that is not amidships, the moment that buys a centimetre of trim, and the two mean draughts of which only one is true.

Five chapters of this volume have heeled MV Ninja sideways. This one tips her lengthways instead, and discovers that the longitudinal problem is the transverse one wearing different units: trim is a list measured in metres of draught difference, the centre of flotation plays the pivot, and MCTC is the exchange rate between moments and centimetres. One new habit matters more than any formula: every distance in a trimming calculation is measured from F, and F is not amidships.

6.1 Trim: the list of the long axis

Trim is the difference between the draughts at the forward and after perpendiculars: draughts of 9.08 m forward and 10.12 m aft make a trim of 1.04 m by the stern; equal draughts make even keel. Like a list, a trim is the ship’s answer to her weights: she trims until the longitudinal centre of buoyancy stands back under the longitudinal centre of gravity, and Chapter 7 will make that sentence into a calculation engine. This chapter builds its three parts: the pivot, the exchange rate, and the sharing rule.

APFPd A 10.12d F 9.08Trim: the list of the long axisthe difference between the draughts at the perpendiculars: here 10.12 − 9.08 = 1.04 m by the sternlist is measured in degrees;trim is the same tilt measured inmetres of draught differenceMV Ninja at the draughts of Worked example 6.1: the mark amidships at the waterline, and 54 t above the summer displacement.
Figure 6.1   Trim is the same tilt as list, measured at the perpendiculars in metres of draught difference.

6.2 The pivot: F, the centre of flotation

A trimming ship rotates about the centroid of her waterplane: the centre of flotation, F, tabulated in the booklet as LCF, measured forward of the after perpendicular. MV Ninja’s waterplane at summer marks is fuller aft than forward, so F sits at 71.84 m foap: 2.16 m abaft of midships. Every trimming moment is a weight times its distance from F: a weight moved s metres contributes w × s directly, and a weight loaded or discharged contributes w times its distance from F. The exchange rate from moments to trim is the booklet’s MCTC column:

Change of Trim (cm) = Trimming Moment ÷ MCTCMCA formula sheet, September 2020
APFPmidships (74.00)F: the trimming axis, 71.84 foapThe pivot is the centroid of the waterplane, not the middle of the shipMV Ninja’s waterplane is fuller aft, so F sits 2.16 m abaft of midships at summer marksevery load, discharge and shift trimsthe ship about this axis: distances intrimming moments are measured from F
Figure 6.2   The trimming axis passes through the centroid of the waterplane, not the middle of the ship.

6.3 Two mean draughts, one truth

Because the ship rotates about F, the draught at F is the one draught that a change of trim cannot touch. It is therefore the draught that means anything: the true mean draught, the hydrostatic draught, the one to take into the tables. The load line mark itself is painted amidships; loading to the summer draught means bringing the draught at F to the summer draught, so that the ship carries her summer displacement and no more. The arithmetic mean of the end draughts equals it only when F is exactly amidships or the trim is zero: neither is usual.

True Mean Draught = Draught aft ± (Trim × LCF ÷ LBP)subtract for stern trim, add for head trim · MCA formula sheet, September 2020
Worked example 6.1

MV Ninja is read at 9.08 m forward, 10.12 m aft. The chief officer notes the mean is 9.600 m, exactly the summer draught, and declares her at her marks. Check the claim.

Trim = 10.12 − 9.08 = 1.04 m by the stern; arithmetic mean draught = 9.600 m: to the eye, precisely legal.

TMD = 10.12 − (1.04 × 71.84 ÷ 148) = 10.12 − 0.505 = 9.615 m.

The draught at F is 1.5 cm more than the summer draught: at TPC 35.28 that is about 54 t more than the summer displacement, even though the mark amidships is exactly at the waterline. The arithmetic mean misleads because F is abaft of midships: with stern trim the waterline is deeper at F than at midships. The tables are entered at F, and loading to the summer draught means bringing the draught at F to 9.60 m.

APFPdraught at midships: the AMD, 9.600draught at F: the TMD, 9.615Two mean draughts, and only one of them is trueF is abaft of midships, so with stern trim the draught at F exceeds the arithmetic meanthe tables are entered with the TMD, the draught at Fhere the AMD of 9.600 puts the mark amidships at the waterline while the TMD of 9.615 has her1.5 cm, about 54 t, above her summer displacement
Figure 6.3   The trap of Worked example 6.1: the mark amidships is at the waterline while the true mean draught, at F, is above the summer draught.
Laboratory 1 · The true mean draught against the arithmetic mean
Summer TMD limit 9.60 m; LCF 71.84 foap, LBP 148, TPC 35.28. Find draught pairs where the arithmetic mean and the true mean draught disagree about whether she is at her summer displacement: with stern trim the AMD flatters her, with head trim it slanders her.

6.4 MCTC: the price of a centimetre

MCTC, the moment to change trim one centimetre, is not an arbitrary tabulated number: it is the longitudinal GM at work. The longitudinal metacentre stands a ship’s length overhead, which is why vessels roll readily but barely pitch, and why trimming moments are priced in hundreds of tonne metres per centimetre.

MCTC = (Δ × GML) ÷ (100 × LBP)MCA formula sheet, September 2020

The booklet’s summer row can be audited on the spot: MCTC 405.7 t m with Δ 30456 t and LBP 148 m gives GML = 405.7 × 14800 ÷ 30456 = 197.1 m: eighty eight times her transverse GM of 2.24 m. One row of the booklet proves the whole anatomy.

transverse GM2.24 mlongitudinal GM L197 m: eighty eight times stifferWhy she rolls but barely pitches: the two metacentric heightsthe longitudinal metacentre stands about a ship’s length overhead, and MCTC is its lever at workMCTC = (Δ × GM L) ÷ (100 × LBP)at summer marks: 30456 × 197.15 ÷ (100 × 148) = 405.7 t m,exactly the booklet’s column: one row proves the whole anatomyMCA formula sheet, September 2020
Figure 6.4   The two metacentric heights drawn to the same scale: this is why she rolls but barely pitches.

6.5 A shift, and the sharing rule

Change of draught aft = Change of trim × LCF ÷ LBP   ·   Change of draught forward = Change of trim × (LBP − LCF) ÷ LBPMCA formula sheet, September 2020
Worked example 6.2

MV Ninja lies at even keel at her summer draught of 9.60 m. 250 t of cargo is shifted 60 m aft. Find the new draughts (MCTC 405.7 t m, LCF 71.84 m foap, LBP 148 m).

Trimming moment = 250 × 60 = 15000 t m by the stern; no weight crossed the rail, so there is no sinkage.

CoT = 15000 ÷ 405.7 = 37.0 cm by the stern.

Shares about F: aft = 37.0 × 71.84 ÷ 148 = 18.0 cm deeper; forward = 37.0 × 76.16 ÷ 148 = 19.0 cm shallower. The forward end moves further because it is further from the pivot. (The change of trim is rounded to 0.1 cm and the shares are taken from the rounded figure so that they add back to it; carried unrounded they are 17.9 and 19.0 cm, and the draughts are the same.)

New draughts: forward 9.60 − 0.190 = 9.41 m; aft 9.60 + 0.180 = 9.78 m. Check: the new trim, 9.78 − 9.41 = 0.37 m, is exactly the computed change of trim: the shares rebuilt the whole.

Faft: + 18.0 cmforward: − 19.0 cmlever aft = LCF = 71.84 mlever forward = LBP − LCF = 76.16 mSharing out a 37 cm change of trim: similar triangles about Feach end moves in proportion to its distance from the pivot, and the two shares must sum to the wholechange aft = CoT × LCF ÷ LBP = 37.0 × 71.84 ÷ 148 = 18.0 cmchange forward = CoT × (LBP − LCF) ÷ LBP = 19.0 cmcheck: 18.0 + 19.0 = 37.0: the shares rebuild the whole
Figure 6.5   Similar triangles about F: each end’s share of the 37 cm is proportional to its lever, and the shares must sum to the whole.
Laboratory 2 · The trim machine: a shifted weight and the swing about F
Even keel 9.60 m start; negative shift is aft. The hull rotates about the red F mark, never about midships: watch the two draught scales move by different amounts, in the ratio of their levers.

6.6 Loading: sinkage plus swing

A loaded or discharged weight does two separate things, and the drill is to price them separately and add at the end: a parallel sinkage of w ÷ TPC centimetres as if the weight had gone aboard at F, then a change of trim of (w × distance from F) ÷ MCTC shared about F by the rule above.

Worked example 6.3

353 t of stores are loaded exactly at the centre of flotation, 71.84 m foap, at summer marks. Find the change in the draughts.

Sinkage = 353 ÷ 35.28 = 10.0 cm; distance from F is zero, so the trimming moment is zero and the trim does not change: both draughts rise 10.0 cm together.

F is the only berth aboard where loading is purely vertical: everywhere else, the ship both sinks and swings.

Worked example 6.4

Instead, 500 t is loaded 30.0 m abaft of F. Find the final draughts from even keel at 9.60 m.

Sinkage = 500 ÷ 35.28 = 14.2 cm, applied to both ends.

CoT = (500 × 30.0) ÷ 405.7 = 37.0 cm by the stern, shared as before: aft +18.0 cm, forward −19.0 cm.

Forward: 9.60 + 0.142 − 0.190 = 9.55 m. Aft: 9.60 + 0.142 + 0.180 = 9.92 m. Same 15000 t m as Worked example 6.2, so the same swing: a load s metres from F trims exactly like a shift of s metres, plus the sinkage.

Worked example 6.5

The second mate argues that loading the 500 t “amidships, at 74.00 m foap” would add no trim at all. Test the claim.

Amidships is 74.00 − 71.84 = 2.16 m forward of F, so the load carries a trimming moment of 500 × 2.16 = 1080 t m by the head.

CoT = 1080 ÷ 405.7 = 2.7 cm by the head: small, but not nothing, and on a draught survey 2.7 cm is real money. The pivot is F, not the midship mark, and the booklet’s LCF column is where it lives.

sinkage 10.0 cm, both ends alike, no change of trimat F: purely verticalsinkage 14.2 cm plus 37 cm of trim shared about Fabaft of F: sinkage and swingThe only berth aboard where loading is purely verticalWorked examples 6.3 and 6.4: the same booklet numbers, opposite behaviourload w tonnes s metres from F: parallel sinkage w ÷ TPC,then a change of trim of (w × s) ÷ MCTC shared about F:two separate sums, added at the end
Figure 6.6   Worked examples 6.3 and 6.4 side by side: at F the ship only sinks; anywhere else she sinks and swings about F.
Laboratory 3 · The loading laboratory: sinkage and change of trim together
Even keel 9.60 m start; negative weight is a discharge. Park the position slider on 71.84 and the swing chips go quiet: the pure sinkage berth. Park it on 74.00 and see the amidships myth cost 2.7 cm. The marks chip warns when the TMD passes 9.60.

6.7 The walking pivot, and a practical

LCF is a column, not a constant. Light, MV Ninja floats on a fine after body and F stands well forward of midships: 77.51 m foap at the 5.00 m ballast draught. Deep, the full stern takes its share of the waterplane and drags F abaft of midships: 71.84 m at summer marks. LCF changes with draught but not with density: fresh water moves the waterline, and F merely follows the shape. MCTC and TPC do change with density, because both contain the displacement: at 9.60 m in fresh water MCTC is 405.7 × 1.000 ÷ 1.025 = 395.8 t m and TPC is 35.28 ÷ 1.025 = 34.42 t/cm, so the same trimming moment changes the trim by more in fresh water. Within a single small problem the course convention holds LCF, TPC and MCTC constant; across large changes of draught they must be re read, which is Chapter 7’s business.

5.0 m6.0 m7.0 m8.0 m9.0 m72747678LCF (m foap)draughtmidships, 74.00summer: 71.84 foap, abaft of midshipsThe pivot walks: LCF against draught from the bookletlight ship floats on a fine after body, F well forward; deep, the full stern drags F abaft of midshipsLCF changes with draught but not with density: a fresh water arrival moves the waterline, and F only follows the shape.
Figure 6.7   The pivot walks: LCF against draught, straight from the booklet’s column.
Worked example 6.6

MV Ninja is loading at draughts 9.13 m forward, 9.71 m aft, and may not exceed her summer TMD of 9.60 m. How much more cargo may she load, and where should it go to keep the calculation honest?

Trim = 0.58 m by the stern; TMD = 9.71 − (0.58 × 71.84 ÷ 148) = 9.71 − 0.282 = 9.428 m.

Rise remaining to the marks = 9.600 − 9.428 = 0.172 m; carrying the unrounded TMD of 9.4285 m it is 17.15 cm.

Cargo = 17.15 × 35.28 = 605 t, loaded at F so the trim, and therefore the TMD arithmetic, is undisturbed. Loaded elsewhere it must be trimmed back or the change of trim allowed for: the deep end may not creep past its marks even though the TMD is lawful.

Chapter 6 in five lines

Trim is the list of the long axis: the draught difference at the perpendiculars, made by LCG and LCB out of line.

The ship trims about F, the centroid of the waterplane: all trimming distances are measured from the LCF column, not from midships.

The true mean draught is the draught at F: enter the tables with it, and trust no arithmetic mean while she is trimmed.

CoT = moment ÷ MCTC, and MCTC is the longitudinal GM at work: 197 m on MV Ninja, which is why she rolls but barely pitches.

A load is a sinkage plus a swing: w ÷ TPC at F, then (w × s) ÷ MCTC shared to the ends by their levers.

Test yourself